Thursday 12 November 2026

Prime Time Takes

The Punchline

SNL Halloween Review: Trump Freezes David S. Pumpkins, Inde Navarrette Ties Up the Boyfriend

Inde Navarrette’s boyfriend duct-taped to his seat with tape over his mouth, giving a double thumbs-up during her SNL monologue

The David S. Pumpkins Trump cold open that kicked off SNL’s Halloween episode gives Tom Hanks about a minute of his ten-year anniversary return. Then James Austin Johnson’s Trump freezes the ride and keeps the floor for the next five. It’s a better Trump opener than most, because the hijack is the structure rather than a delay. Inde Navarrette’s monologue is shorter and looser: a costume parade with one great sight gag and a cast member hustling for a Marvel part.

Any Questions? The Pumpkins Setup

The sketch starts properly. Kenan Thompson is the ghoulish guide on a haunted crypt ride. Carly, one of the riders, threatens to pass out on every turn until her friend tells her to either do it or stop talking about it. A Lizzie Borden scare goes as planned.

Then the doors open on David S. Pumpkins, flanked by Mikey Day and Bobby Moynihan in skeleton suits, and the ride stops making sense. Who is he? A Halloween guy. And the skeletons? Next to him. Ten years on, the character still runs on the same rule: the less he explains himself, the funnier it gets.

Why the David S. Pumpkins Trump Cold Open Works

Just as the second Pumpkins scene ends, Trump pauses it. He announces himself as “your one true god,” asks the audience if they’re sad about missing the third Pumpkins scene, and summarises it for them: he keeps popping up and confusing people, the end.

That’s the smart part. Pumpkins was always a sketch that refused to resolve, so a cold open that refuses to resolve it suits him. Behind Trump, Hanks, Day and Moynihan stand frozen like waxworks for the rest of the segment. Trump’s kinship pitch is the strongest stretch of his monologue: they both appeared in 2016, and both are loud, orange and, frankly, annoying. Every word of it checks out.

Kenan refuses to stay frozen. When Trump thanks him for a donation, he gets a two-word answer ending in “bitch,” the right man in the right moment to break the tableau. The asides about Moynihan flying in and not shaving land less well. The Hanks-should-be-narrating-WWII-documentaries gag sits in between.

The Runner That Won’t Quit

The cold open’s real engine is Trump’s newfound habit of admiring men’s backsides. He compliments Hanks first, then explains the condition as “gay dementia” and works out a backronym for it on the spot. He keeps returning to it, and that is the point: a man insisting it’s nothing while bringing it up for the third time.

It’s at its best when it collides with the midterm pitch. With the election on Tuesday and Texas looking close, Trump begs viewers to vote for Ken Paxton while calling him an ugly son of a bitch he can’t stand. In the same breath he mangles James Talarico’s name and praises his rear end. An endorsement delivered with open contempt for the candidate is the most character-true joke in the segment.

The only quibble is that the runner keeps the same shape each time it returns. It loops rather than escalates. The rally grunt (“Ugh. A new sound just dropped”) needs the audience to know the real-world clip, though the Epstein line attached to it is sharp enough to carry it.

Nicki the Trumpie and the Flubbed Line

New cast member Saidah Belo-Osagie arrives as Nicki Minaj, pitched as Trump’s next press secretary. She’s “killing it,” and by “it” she means her career. The premise is clear, but the throwaway intro, “the late, great Nicki Minaj,” is funnier than anything Minaj says once she’s on stage.

The closer works. Trump gives his former press secretary Katie Zacharia, fired after less than a week, a chance to redeem herself with the show’s signature line. She says it “with confidence,” whiffs it (“Liv from New York”), and Hanks gets unfrozen to deliver it properly. That’s one last use for the frozen cast, and a clean exit.

Inde Navarrette’s SNL Monologue: A Chill Relationship

Navarrette opens by insisting she’s nothing like Nikki, her character in Obsession. Her boyfriend is in the audience, she says, and they have such a chill relationship. He is duct-taped to his seat, arms pinned and mouth covered, giving a double thumbs-up. She praises him with “Good job,” and moves on.

It’s the best joke in the monologue, and it works because she never acknowledges that anything is strange. The Obsession reference lands without a word of setup.

“Long for De” is the runner-up. People ask whether Inde is short for Indiana, and she explains it’s actually long for De. It’s a clean anti-joke, delivered as if it settles the matter.

The Marvel stretch is quicker. She’s playing Rogue in the X-Men reboot, Marvel wants its actors fit, so every morning she puts on her little whore outfit and hits the gym. It’s a Halloween line in a Halloween episode, and it does what it needs to.

The Costume Rundown

Since the cast can’t go out on Halloween, they show off their costumes instead:

  • Marcello Hernández, sexy TSA agent. One joke: shoes off, step into his big, nasty machine. It’s a quick hit with nowhere further to go.
  • Kam Patterson, “the bad lady with the blood.” He doesn’t know he’s dressed as Elizabeth Holmes. People won’t stop talking about her, so he’s meeting them halfway. It’s the best costume bit, a character entirely at peace with not knowing what he is.
  • Jeremy Culhane, Wolverine. A cast member openly auditioning for the still-uncast role, with Navarrette hiding behind Marvel’s no-comment culture. Her “Get away from me” is the right ending, even if the “Inde movie” pun is the weakest link.
  • Grace Reiter, a bird. It’s a group costume, and the rest of the group is a cast member’s Kelly Clarkson, who demands to buy the bird until it turns into a song. It’s the biggest swing of the night, and it lands only if you followed the internet’s feud over a singing automaton that wasn’t for sale.

Verdict

The David S. Pumpkins Trump cold open is the stronger half. Its hijack gives a regular political monologue a shape, and its stars treat the frozen set like a working prop rather than wallpaper. Navarrette’s monologue is functional rather than memorable. It’s carried by one excellent sight gag, one perfect anti-joke and an unbothered delivery that suits deadpan denial better than costume patter.

Did the David S. Pumpkins Trump cold open earn its hijack, or did you want the third Pumpkins scene? Tell me in the comments, and follow Prime Time Takes on Threads, Bluesky and Facebook.

Your take

Discover more from Prime Time Takes

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading